This is a splendid mystery. The maker of this superbly cast bronze woman is unknown, and the subject is uncertain. The nude woman opens her mouth, seeming to shout, showing her finely chased teeth, while turning away from the source of her fear and covering the front of her body with her hands. This is a pose from classical sculpture called Venus pudica, or “modest Venus,” in which a woman covers her body, especially her genitals, with her hands. In the past, scholars have associated her with the biblical and mythological stories of women who have been menaced or intruded upon in some way: she has been called Susannah, who, in the Bible, was spied upon, while bathing, by a group of lusty male elders; and she has been called Diana, the goddess from classical mythology, who, also at her bath, was surprised by Actaeon.
The mystery of her pose raises the question of whether this bronze was originally conceived as part of a group, or if, perhaps, she was meant to be cowering from her Renaissance male viewer. She and small bronzes like her were meant to be grasped and manipulated by their owners and viewers, and it was in doing so that the extraordinary details of her making would have become apparent: the delicate chasing of her hair, eyes, and teeth; the extremely fine lines of her fingernails and of the wrinkles on the palms of her hands; the now-tarnished silver pins inset as her eyes and her nipples. The artist may have been associated with Mantua, because the bronze’s enraged expression resembles the often-impassioned figures of the Mantuan artist Andrea Mantegna. Beyond that, however, she is an enigma. The object is singular among the small bronzes of the Renaissance that survive today.
Nude Female Figure (Shouting Woman)
Although this figure was once attributed to Riccio, certain of its technical features would be unique in his work and are more characteristic of bronzes from the circle of the Mantuan sculptor Antico. The bronze seems to have been designed as a pseudo-antique, with traces of a green patination that emulates natural corrosion and silver inlaid eyes and nipples such as can be found in Hellenistic bronzes or Mantuan imitations of them. The pose echoes the classical gestures of a Venus Pudica. No known sculpture by Riccio attempts such a deceptively antique guise. The startled, angry face of the woman suggests familiarity with Mantuan art, for she strongly resembles the often impassioned figures painted by Andrea Mantegna.
The subject of the bronze has sometimes been identified as Susanna surprised at her bath by the elders, but a biblical heroine seems an unlikely source for such a classicizing bronze. Diana surprised by Actaeon at her bath would be more appropriate to both the form and character of the figure. Her nudity, pose, and expression befit an outraged goddess and infuse this antiquarian bronze with energizing naturalism. The modeling and finish are exceptionally refined, as can be seen in the delicately detailed hair, fingers, and feet.
Source: Art in The Frick Collection: Paintings, Sculpture, Decorative Arts, New York: Harry N. Abrams, 1996.
Comte Jacques de Bryas, Paris. Sold through Durlacher, April 19, 1904, for £3,000 to J. Pierpont Morgan, London and New York. Duveen. Frick, 1916.
Source: Sculpture in The Frick Collection: Italian. Volume III. New York: The Frick Collection, 1970.